Skip to main content

4 Different Quantifiable attributes that measure Risk and how same dollar investments can have different Risks

Here are different quantifiable attributes that measure risk: stock borrow / lending rate, historical volatility, implied volatility and margin.

#1 Stock Borrow / Lending Rate 

This is the rate at which it costs to borrow securities (if you want to sell them short) and the corresponding rate to lend securities to someone that wants to borrow them.  For example, this is quoted on Interactive Brokers "SLB Rates", SPY has a Fee rate of 0.25% and a Rebate rate of -0.25%.  While BITO has a Fee rate of 0.91% and a Rebate rate of -0.91%.  This means that it will cost less to borrow SPY than BITO and also that if you lend BITO you will make more money than lending SPY.  Generally, if things cost more to borrow, they have more risk associated with them.

#2 Historical (or Realized) Volatility

This number is calculated from historical prices.  It is basically the standard deviation of prices over a given time window and then normalized into an annualized number so that it can be easily compared.  For example, the 10 Historical Volatility for SPY is 8.8% while for BITO it is 58.5%.  In other words, BITO is more than 6 times as volatile as SPY.  In Interactive Brokers, these numbers can be found in Option Analysis -> Volatility Over Time -> Historical Volatility

#3 Implied Volatility

This can be found by using an options pricing model like Black-Scholes to fix all other variables (Forward Price, Interest Rates and Dividends) and solve for the uncertainty implied in the future price.  For Example in 28 day At-the-money (where the price currently is) put options for SPY are 1.6% of current price implying 12.8% volatility while BITO put options are 9.2% of current price implying 84.9% volatility.  In Interactive Brokers, these numbers can be found in the "Option Chain".

#4 Margin

This amount determines how much capital you will need to have a position.  For a Portfolio Margin account at Interactive Brokers, SPY requires 25%, while BITO requires 50%.  This means if you want to buy $100,000 worth of SPY you will only need to have $25,000 while for the same amount of exposure in BITO you would need $50,000.  In Interactive Brokers, you can see this number before you execute a trade or you can use the IB Risk Navigator application and see the Margin Sensitivity Section.

Final Notes

From the above notes, often Stock Borrow / Lending Rate and Margin can be similar for very liquid stocks.  The Historical (Realized) Volatility and the Implied Volatility are more unique and are the foundation for modern risk assessment.  These numbers can help illustrate that risk associated with investments can be very different than the capital allocated and can contextualize the magnitude of risk.  For example, if using Historical Volatility as a measure, $100 invested in BITO is more than 6 times as risky as $100 invested in SPY.

SPY - ETF for S&P 500 Index

BITO - ETF for Bitcoin Futures Fund

 




Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Comparing the exposure of ETF, futures, and index options for S&P 500 (SPY, SPX, ES) and Nasdaq 100 (QQQ, NDX, NQ)

The S&P 500 and the NASDAQ 100 are two of the most popular stock indexes.  Below are tables that show different ways of getting exposure to these stock indexes. S&P 500 Index Exposures: Product Price multiplier exposure SPY equivalent shares option contract exposure SPY equivalent option contract exposure SPY ETF 445 1 $445 1 $44,452 1 ES Futures 4,463 50 $223,156 502 $223,156 5 MES Futures 4,463 5 $22,316 50 $22,316 0.5 SPX Index 4,463 100 $446,312 1004 $446,312 10 XSP Index 446 100 $44,631 100 $44,631 1 1 SPX Index option has roughly the same exposure as 10 SPY ETF options From the above table, you can see that depending on how much exposure you want, you can pick from a variety of products.  For pure delta exposure, SPY ETF and ES Futures are the most liquid.  For options, SPX Index and SPY options have the most liquidity.  There are definitely other ETFs, like IVV, VOO, or SPLG with lower expense ratios, but suffer from options volume and have a wider bi...
Post a Comment
Read more

Trading Ethereum (ETH) merge? Are the CME Ethereum Options on Micro Futures markets reasonable?

Ethereum Merge Brief Background Most people are aware of Proof-of-Work (consensus mechanism to validate blocks on the blockchain - this is done with miners solving math problems (work)).  Ethereum, the second largest Crypto Currency is moving from a Proof-of-Work to Proof-of-Stake (consensus mechanism that validates blocks through a validator (like voting) system).   The main reason for doing this is to get away from miners wasting electricity solving useless math problems to a system that doesn't waste energy on miners.   One argument against moving to Proof-of-Stake, is that it becomes more about controlling a large number of validator nodes (so in a sense, the larger validators have more say, whereas Proof-Of-Work rewards are more 'fair' as it is randomly distributed. Either way you look at it being positive or negative, it is an event that can be traded as the current estimated merge date (the date the blockchain switches from Proof-of-Work to Proof-of-Stake...
Post a Comment
Read more

How does theta change through time when selling strangles? SPY, META, IEF

What is Theta? Theta is amount of value that an option position changes each day due to the passage of time.   For example, SPY closing at 411.99 and Implied Volatility (IVOL) 22.58% SPY 9/16/22 (47 DTE) Strike delta price theta 376P -0.15 3.12 -0.09 440C 0.15 1.97 -0.07 The above table shows that the 376 Put has a theta of -0.09.  This means the option will lose $9 a day (each contract represents 100 shares so -0.09 x 100 = -$9. To standardize, the theta/price is a ratio that can be used.  In our example  -$9/411.99 => -0.02%. Table of Theta for 15 delta Strangles for SPY, META, and IEF Information was pulled from market data on 7/31/2022 taking the initial strikes and seeing how the data changes for different upcoming Days to Expiration (DTE).  (15 delta Strangles for SPY correspond to 376P and 440C). SPY is the most active ETF for S&P 500. IEF is an ETF of 10 year Bonds. META is the ticker for the company formerly known as Facebook. Analysis 1) T...
Post a Comment
Read more